close
Larchmont Chronicle logo

OPINION: When antisemitism dresses itself as virtue

| October 29, 2026 | 0 Comments

As a volunteer contributor to the Larchmont Chronicle, I have tried to acknowledge competing arguments. But fairness does not require giving historical distortion the same standing as evidence or overlooking prejudice because it speaks the language of social justice, including when Zionism is declared evil.

Zionism, at its core, supports Jewish national self-determination in the Jewish ancestral homeland. It does not require supporting Benjamin Netanyahu, every Israeli military decision, or any particular boundary. Treating it as evil turns the belief that Jews deserve a national home into moral depravity.

Calling someone a “Zio” replaces engagement with contempt. When “Zionist” becomes shorthand for a sinister, controlling presence responsible for the world’s problems, old antisemitic ideas have acquired new packaging.

The far right offers white supremacy, Holocaust denial, and conspiracies about Jewish power. Charlottesville’s “Jews will not replace us” chant was unmistakable. Parts of the far left use another vocabulary: Jews become foreign colonizers, Jewish national identity becomes uniquely unacceptable, and collective blame becomes a badge of solidarity and moral value. The horseshoe fits. Political extremes can converge on the same prejudice, and neither should excuse antisemitism from its allies.

Criticizing Israel, supporting Palestinian rights, and opposing Netanyahu are not inherently antisemitic. Denying a people’s history, celebrating the murder of its civilians, or holding Jews everywhere responsible are different. Nor does directing hostility at “Israel” or “Zionists” automatically preclude antisemitism. There are dozens of Muslim-majority countries, several constitutionally Islamic states, and many nations organized around ethnic, religious, or national identities. Their governments can be criticized without demanding that their countries cease to exist. Why is Jewish self-determination subjected to a test applied to virtually no one else?

Jewish ties to the land long predate modern Israel. The kingdoms of Israel and Judah existed there more than 1,500 years before the Arab-Muslim conquest, and Jewish communities remained through centuries of changing rulers. Modern Zionism emerged in the 19th century. For more than 75 years before statehood, Jews legally bought land under Ottoman and British rule, including from Arab owners and absentee landlords.

The claim that Jews arrived from Europe and stole someone else’s country erases that history and the Middle Eastern and North African origins of much of Israel’s Jewish population. Roughly one-fifth of Israel’s citizens are Arab. They possess citizenship and voting rights; serve in the Knesset, judiciary and professions; and participate throughout Israeli society, even though significant inequalities and discrimination remain.

Genetic research supports shared Middle Eastern ancestry among major Jewish diaspora populations, including Ashkenazi Jews, and deep regional ancestry among Palestinians. Genetics is no title deed. Both peoples have genuine ancestral connections; neither must deny the other.

Before Israel, the territory was ruled by the Ottomans and then administered under the British Mandate, not as a Palestinian state. That does not diminish Palestinian identity or aspirations. By 1947, Jews were approximately one-third of the population. The UN proposed Jewish and Arab states. Jewish leaders accepted partition despite its extensive arid Negev territory; Arab leaders rejected it and neighboring Arab armies invaded.

Palestinian displacement, including expulsions, was a genuine tragedy. So was the subsequent flight and expulsion of hundreds of thousands of Jews from Arab countries. A history acknowledging only one people’s losses is incomplete.

From 1948 to 1967, Jordan controlled the West Bank and Egypt administered Gaza; neither became a Palestinian state. Israel later returned the Sinai Peninsula to Egypt for an enduring peace. President Clinton’s 2000 parameters envisioned Gaza, 94–96% of the West Bank, land swaps, and Palestinian sovereignty over Arab East Jerusalem. Both sides accepted with reservations, but no agreement emerged. Later negotiations also failed.

In 2005, Israel removed its settlements and permanent ground forces from Gaza. Hamas won the 2006 Palestinian legislative election and seized control there by force in 2007. The withdrawal did not resolve every dispute, but it was real. Years of rocket attacks into Israel followed.

The claim that Israel never wanted peace makes it permanently guilty, denies Palestinian leaders’ agency and turns hostility toward the Jewish state into virtue.

Then came October 7. Hamas-led attackers murdered approximately 1,200 people and abducted 251. They shot families in their homes and young people at a music festival, committed rape and other sexual violence, tortured victims, burned and suffocated people inside their homes, and mutilated and desecrated bodies. The murder of civilians and taking of hostages were purposes of the attack, not incidental consequences.

The question too often missing is: What would you do?

If an armed organization murdered your citizens in their homes and at a music festival, kidnapped others and intended to attack again, how would you protect your population, recover hostages and confront fighters operating through tunnels and civilian neighborhoods while protecting the people around them?

It is easy to say what you would not do. A serious moral argument must confront what you would do.

The dilemma is documented. Amnesty International reported Hamas’ use of an al-Shifa Hospital outpatient clinic for detention and interrogation during the 2014 conflict. Four hostages were rescued from residential buildings in Nuseirat in 2024.

The United Nations investigated only 19 United Nations Relief and Works Agency employees accused over October 7, not its workforce of thousands. It found evidence indicating that nine may have participated, and they were terminated. That neither establishes agency-wide guilt nor gives everyone never examined a clean bill of health.

More fundamentally, UNRWA has administered Palestinian refugee eligibility across generations while lacking the principal UN refugee agency’s general mandate to pursue permanent solutions through resettlement or local integration. An institution created to address a refugee crisis has instead helped institutionalize it for more than seven decades.

Hamas official Mousa Abu Marzouk said the tunnels protected fighters and that protecting civilians was the responsibility of the UN and Israel. Hamas used hundreds of tunnel miles for fighters, commanders, weapons and hostages, not ordinary families. The calculation was clear: if Israel refrained from striking civilian areas, Hamas survived; if Israel struck and civilians died, Hamas gained devastating images. It exploited Israel’s concern for civilians while benefiting politically from their deaths. Hamas has also executed and tortured Palestinians accused of collaboration or opposition, with little comparable outrage.

Egypt also largely refused to admit Gazans seeking general refuge, citing security and permanent-displacement concerns, yet that decision generated only a fraction of the outrage directed at Israel.

Combatants do not become immune by hiding among civilians, who retain their protection. Israel must distinguish military targets, take feasible precautions, and avoid attacks whose expected civilian harm would be excessive relative to the anticipated military advantage. Those are the laws of war, not an assertion that Israel violated them.

Let me be explicit: Palestinian civilian deaths are terrible. A child killed in Gaza is not a debating point. Hunger, displacement, and families destroyed are human catastrophes. Hamas’ conduct does not excuse unlawful Israeli actions, and defending Israel does not require defending every soldier or decision.

We must face that suffering without looking away while still asking honestly what it proves. The horror of civilian deaths does not, by itself, establish genocide. If civilian death and devastation were enough to make a war genocidal, then every war in which civilians suffered would qualify as genocide, and the word would no longer describe a distinct crime requiring an intent to destroy a people.

The genocide accusation transforms a terrible war into a simple story of Jewish evil, turns Hamas’ victims into oppressors, and allows its proponents to regard themselves as enlightened. That is why the facts cannot be avoided.

Gaza’s Hamas-run Health Ministry reports more than 74,000 deaths, approximately 3.4% of the prewar population. Its total does not distinguish civilians from combatants. Estimates vary, but commonly cited assessments place combatants at between one-third and one-half of the dead, approximately one to two civilians for each combatant. The United Nations has reported that civilians can account for approximately 90% of those killed or injured when explosive weapons are used in populated areas. Although the measures are not identical, the contrast provides important context.

It has been reported that Israel used approximately 200,000 tons of munitions and damaged or destroyed much of Gaza’s building stock. Yet after two years of major combat, roughly 97% of Gaza’s prewar population remained alive. No percentage alone determines intent. But given Israel’s overwhelming power, the scale of the bombing, and the combatant estimate, it is absurd to conclude that eradicating Palestinians was its objective.

The record reinforces that conclusion. By March 31, 2024, the Israel Defense Force reported approximately 9.3 million evacuation leaflets, 15.5 million texts, more than 17 million prerecorded messages and 100,000 individual calls. Israeli figures reported approximately 1.87 million tons of aid entering through July 2025. A peer-reviewed study by Israeli researchers using COGAT shipment data calculated an average supply of 3,004 calories per person per day from January through July 2024 after projected losses. Even assuming 30 percent loss, it exceeded the Sphere humanitarian standard. Food did not always reach every family, but distribution failures and theft cannot become proof of an intent to starve.

Israel’s eleven-week suspension of aid in spring 2025, amid hostage negotiations and disputes over Hamas diversion, may have gone too far in its breadth. Deliveries resumed, and that episode does not outweigh the broader evidence contradicting an intent to starve the population. World Health Organization also reported nearly 603,000 children vaccinated against polio in February 2025 after campaigns requiring coordination and pauses in military activity.

No precaution eliminates civilian casualties when an enemy deliberately operates among civilians. But a military intent on extermination does not warn civilians by the millions, direct them away from operations, facilitate humanitarian aid and coordinate campaigns to vaccinate their children. Those actions are powerful evidence of an effort to preserve life and cannot be erased from an assessment of intent.

Critics also cite appalling statements by some Israeli politicians as evidence of genocidal intent. Such rhetoric deserves condemnation. But statements by individual officials—some without authority over military operations—do not by themselves establish the purpose of an entire military campaign or override the evidence of actual policy and conduct. Intent must be judged from the totality of the record.

A UN commission, human-rights organizations, and scholars have accused Israel of genocide. Other scholars, military experts, legal authorities, and public figures reject it. More than 6,000 people recently signed an open letter doing so, including Deborah Lipstadt, Dina Porat, Steven Pinker, Niall Ferguson, Benny Morris, Judea Pearl and former Canadian justice minister Irwin Cotler. Authority exists on both sides. Evidence must decide the question.

Automatic deference to the UN is unwarranted. UN Watch tallied 173 General Assembly resolutions against Israel from 2015 through 2024, compared with 80 against every other country combined; in 2025, it counted 15 versus 11. Since 2006, the Human Rights Council has condemned Israel more often than Syria, Iran, Russia and Venezuela combined, and Israel alone has a permanent country-specific agenda item. Counts do not disprove an allegation, but this disparity defeats claims of impartiality.

Looking at Israel’s capabilities, the reported death toll, combatant estimates, warnings, humanitarian measures, and objective of defeating Hamas, I reject the accusation. This was a terrible and destructive war. It was not genocide.

Repeating the accusation does more than mischaracterize a war. It brands the Jewish state as an extermination project and Jews who defend its existence as accomplices to mass murder. That is where factual dishonesty, intellectual laziness, and antisemitism converge.

Politicians, celebrities, professors, and activists who casually repeat the accusation are not necessarily displaying courage. Too often, they are engaging in irresponsible virtue-signaling to win votes, applause, followers, or acceptance within their tribe. The accusation and its consequences are too grave for an applause line.

Images of devastation are powerful because the suffering is real. But when they erase Hamas’ agency or romanticize terrorism as “resistance,” they advance the propaganda of an organization that has brutalized Israelis and Palestinians alike. October 7’s victims become merely representatives of an oppressor. Intellectual laziness reduces everything to a simple hierarchy: The stronger side must be evil and the weaker righteous. Antisemitism supplies something darker, a readiness to believe the worst about Jews and dismiss whatever complicates the accusation. Israel can be powerful and its citizens still be victims. Palestinians can suffer terribly without Hamas becoming their innocent defender.

Many people enter these movements from a sincere desire for social justice. But movements provide belonging and moral certainty, and once membership becomes part of someone’s identity, questioning the movement can feel like rejecting part of oneself. Slogans replace inquiry and conformity passes for conviction, a psychology recognizable in MAGA and parts of the activist left.

In parts of the far left hostility toward Israel has become a litmus test. A person can oppose Netanyahu, support Palestinian rights, and advocate two states yet still be declared unwelcome for refusing to denounce Zionism itself. When belonging requires repudiating Jewish national self-determination, exclusion is being presented as moral principle.

Selective outrage deserves scrutiny too. Nearly 5,000 Palestinian refugees were reported killed in Syria, including roughly 1,600 associated with Yarmouk. More than 500,000 people were killed in Syria’s war. The UN projected 377,000 direct and indirect deaths from Yemen’s war by the end of 2021. Roughly 300,000 were killed in the earlier Darfur conflict, and Saddam Hussein’s Anfal campaign killed an estimated 50,000 to 100,000 Kurds. Thousands of Yazidis were murdered and abducted. The Rohingya, Uyghurs, and civilians in Congo have suffered mass persecution and killing, while Iran has killed protesters, accelerated executions, and helped sustain Assad’s slaughter.

Where were the comparable campus encampments, occupied buildings, boycotts, and demands that those countries cease to exist? This is not whataboutism. Wrongdoing elsewhere cannot excuse wrongdoing by Israel. It is a question about selective moral fury directed at the world’s only Jewish state.

Unequal attention alone does not prove antisemitism. But when it combines with historical erasure, collective blame, contempt for Jewish self-determination, and an eagerness to accuse the world’s only Jewish state of genocide, the pattern deserves a name.

Palestinian leadership deserves scrutiny. The US Treasury identified a Hamas investment portfolio exceeding $500 million. An IMF investigation found approximately $900 million in Palestinian Authority revenue diverted between 1995 and 2000 into an account controlled by Yasser Arafat, although not necessarily as personal property. Despite enormous international assistance, corruption, repression, and leaders’ enrichment have undermined ordinary Palestinians. For too many Palestinian leaders, perpetuating conflict has brought money, power, and international relevance that building a peaceful and accountable state might threaten. Concern for Palestinians requires holding their leaders accountable, not treating them as spectators without agency.

Two states remain my goal. But that requires Palestinian leaders who intend to build a state alongside Israel, not in its place. Hamas plainly rejects that future. Fatah and the Palestinian Authority must provide honest leadership, reject terrorism, and credibly accept Israel’s permanent existence. Without that transformation, no Israeli government can responsibly entrust its citizens’ security to promises of peaceful coexistence.

Netanyahu is also a serious obstacle. His opposition to a credible Palestinian state, empowerment of the far right, divisiveness, attempts to weaken democratic institutions and judicial safeguards, and serious corruption charges have made peace substantially harder.

I am unequivocally opposed to what his government is enabling in the West Bank. Settlement expansion, legalized outposts, settler attacks on Palestinian civilians and property, inadequate accountability, and displacement are morally wrong and steadily destroy the possibility of a viable Palestinian state. Israel has legitimate security needs, and terrorist organizations operating out of Gaza are real. Neither justifies attacks on innocent Palestinians or entrenching permanent Israeli control. Netanyahu and his partners should not be mistaken for the whole of Israeli history or allowed to erase its record of partition, territorial withdrawals, land for peace, and negotiations toward Palestinian statehood.

Palestinians deserve freedom, dignity, and statehood. Israelis deserve security and national self-determination. Neither person is going away, and neither can achieve a durable future through leaders committed to permanent conflict.

A just future requires recognizing both and refusing to let antisemitism pass as virtue.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

Category: People

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Upcoming Events

  • Thanksgiving Day

  • Delivery of the December edition of the Larchmont Chronicle

View All Events

Sponsored Articles